Showing posts with label Consumer Rights Day; Financial Services. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Consumer Rights Day; Financial Services. Show all posts

Saturday, March 17, 2012

WCRD – Financial Services revisited



Today is the World Consumer Rights Day which is celebrated by the consumer movement around the world. This year is special since it is 50 years since President John F Kennedy set out a vision of consumer rights and recognized consumers as a group. Since then the set of rights identified by President Kennedy formed the basis for the 8 consumer rights accepted today – the rights to basic needs, choose, information, education, redress, safety, be heard and healthy environment.

This year’s theme is again financial services. The reason is simple. After the debacle of the financial crisis some years ago, it seems that the lessons which were learned have now been forgotten. Consumers around the world are getting a bad deal from financial services. A lack of effective competition in the market makes it difficult, if not impossible, for them to shop around.

For example, consumers often have trouble understanding different financial products, whether due to a lack of information or because the products themselves are too complex, or both.

Furthermore, changing to a different provider can be challenging, either because the switching process is prohibitively complicated, or simply because there are not enough financial institutions in the market competing to provide better deals.

This is also recognized by two EU Commissioners, Barnier and Dalli. The former in a statement said "Financial markets should be at the service of citizens, not the other way around. Europe must make financial services more fair and transparent for consumers everywhere in Europe”. Dalli on the other hand, recognized that “consumers are often overpaying for their basic financial services and do not always get effective redress they deserve. The European Commission has not been passive in the face of this.” In fact, there are a number of projects that will be launched in an attempt to improve the situation in the EU.

But what is the situation in Malta? Though the recent financial turmoil did not hit directly our banking system, thousands of small investors practically lost their life’s savings through the advice they got from ‘experts’ in the financial sector. It is a misfortune that we still lack data of the estimated amount Maltese investors lost through the financial turmoil and we are more disappointed that the banking system seems to be exerting its advertising muscle in the media to stifle any real discussion on this subject.

In a recent study by the European Commission covering all 27 EU countries, 8 out of 10 mystery shoppers encountered problems when switching financial providers. In Malta, none of the 10 mystery shoppers could successfully complete a switch. Mind you, the sample of banks selected was based on those brands with the highest share of bank accounts. This goes a long way to show the real deal Maltese consumers are getting from the financial sector. Above is a graph taken from the study* which encapsulates the situation in Malta.

I remember that, some years ago, soon after the introduction of the Common Principles on Banking Account Switching, I wrote an article where I made reference to my own experience. I had visited three branches of the three largest banks in Malta and I asked for information since I was aware that the Malta Bankers’ Association has prepared a leaflet on the subject. I found that none had the leaflet and none of the staff really knew about it. Even after some telephone calls only in one occasion was the bank able to provide me, with the press release. I also criticized the fact that the prepared leaflet was full of legal jargon and not understandable to the ‘average’ consumer. I also remember that I was criticized by some people for being too harsh. If anything, the above shows that the situation is still the same. It also shows that self-regulation is ineffective in Malta.

We sincerely hope that the World Consumers Rights Day will not be just another day. The Consumers Association will continue to press to have a regulator that:

  • tells consumers what it does and publishes its investigations;
  • is strong and stands up to the banks and for consumers and promotes competition;
  • is proactive and acts on issues before they become problems.

*Report on “Consumer Market Study on the consumers’ experiences with bank account switching with reference to the Common Principles on Banking Account Switching” produced by GfK and published by the EU Commission which shows the situation on bank account transfers.

Article published in the Times of Malta 15th March 2012

Wednesday, March 17, 2010

Flus, Drittijietna, Jum il-Konsumaturi, 2010

Il-krizi finanzjarja li laqtet id-dinja riċentament għadha qiegħda tħalli l-effetti tagħha. L-akbar effetti huma fuq il-konsumaturi, speċjalment dawk li raw it-tfaddil tagħhom jogħsfor mil-lejl għan-nhar. Fil-fatt hu stmat li l-akbar effett kellhom iħallsuh il-konsumaturi. Hu għalhekk li sew il-Consumers’ Interational u l-BEUC, il-vuċi tal-konsumaturi Ewropew adattaw din it-tema. Il-BEUC, min-naħa l-oħra ħarġet sett ta’ proposti. Dawn il-proposti jinkludu:


Regolamenti u superviżjoni effettiva fuq is-sistema finanzjarja
Hemm bżonn ta’ regoli Ewropej li jorbtu aktar il-banek u l-istituzzjonijiet finanzjarji għax l-aħħar kriżi wriet li dawn mhumiex kapaċi jikkontrollaw lilhom infushom. Prodotti finanzjarji ġodda hemm bżonn li jkunu evalwati għar-riskju li jġorru. Il-BEUC qiegħda titlob għal regolaturi aktar indipendenti u effettivi biex jaqdu dawn id-dmirijiet fost l-oħrajn:

Jaraw li r-reklamar ikun ġust u fih l-informazzjoni biex il-konsumaturi jkunu jistgħu jagħmlu għażliet tajba;

Jitwaqqfu prattiċi inġusti bħal prodotti marbuta ma’ xulxin;


Iwaqqfu sistema ta’ infor-mazzjoni biex javżaw lill-konsumaturi fuq ir-riskji li jġorru ċerti prodotti finanzjarji tul iż-żmien, speċjalment meta l-affarijiet ikunu sejrin ħażin.


Informazzjoni aktar f’waqtha u sempliċi fuq il-prodotti finanzjarji
L-informazzjoni għandha tkun miktuba b’mod sempliċi, b’mod li tindika r-riskju, l-volatilità u l-ispejjeż biex il-prodotti offruti jistgħu jkunu mqabbla. Ix-xogħol li qiegħda tagħmel CESR, Committee for European Securities Regulators, hu importanti. Il-metodu modern użat, speċjalment mill-banek hu li jipprovdulek pataflun ta’ informazzjoni teknika biex filwaqt li huma jkunu protetti, il-konsumatur xorta ma jifhem xejn u jkollu jiddependi ħafna drabi fuq pariri ta’ min qed imexxi l-istess prodotti.

Pariri indipendenti

Ir-regolaturi hemm bżonn li jinvestu biex ikun hemm minn jagħti pariri indipendenti bi prezz raġonevoli.


Self responsabbli
Hu importanti li l-bank li jkun qed jislef jassigura li l-konsumaturi jkunu kapaċi li jħallsu d-dejn li jagħmlu. Iżda hemm bżonn ukoll li jkun hemm limitu għal varjazzjoni tal-interessi.


Protezzjoni ugwali fis-suq Ewropew

Is-sistemi ta’ protezzjoni tad-depożiti (Deposit Guarantee Schemes) hemm bżonn li joffru l-istess protezzjoni u li dawn ikunu attrezzati biex iħallsu malajr. Hu b’hekk biss li l-konsumaturi jkunu jistgħu jgawdu mis-Suq Ewropew Wieħed. Dan jgħodd speċjalment għal Malta fejn is-suq hu żgħir u l-kompetizzjoni, speċjalment f’dan il-qasam, hi waħda limitata. Minħabba li ħafna skemi mhux iffinanzjati sew, hu l-konsumatur li qed ikollu jħallas għall-fallimenti permezz tat-taxxi tiegħu minflok l-operaturi stess kif titlob id-Direttiva.


Tmexxija serja u responsabbli

Hemm bżonn ta’ aktar superviżjoni stretta, barra li hemm bżonn ta’ aktar trasparenza u akkontabilità fil-ħlas tal-managers. Hemm il-ħtieġa li dawn il-ħlasijiet ikunu marbuta ma’ kif imorru l-investimenti fuq medda ta’ snin itwal.

Legiżlazzjoni l-istess fuq financial intermediaries

Il-BEUC tisħaq li hemm bżonn li l-ħlasijiet inizjali jispiċċaw filwaqt li hemm bżonn ta’ regoli uniformi fis-Suq Wieħed li jinkludu regoli dwar reġistrazzjoni, kwalifiki, trasparenza u insurance.


Rimedji
Hu kkalkolat li hemm madwar 40% tal-Ewropej li jemmnu li s-settur finanzjarju hu l-aktar wieħed diffiċli biex int tieħu rimedju minħabba li, speċjalment il-banek, għandhom riżorsi u diterminazzjoni biex jaqtgħu qalb il-konsumatur milli jieħu raġun. Għalhekk il-konsumaturi qiegħdin jitolbu biex tkun tista’ tittieħed azzjoni kollettiva (group action) f’dan il-qasam anki fuq livell komunitarju.


Hu żgur li dawn il-proposti se jsibu oppożizzjoni, speċjalment mill-banek u l-istituzzjo-nijiet l-oħra finanzjarji, bl-iskuża li issa l-inqas ħaġa li hemm bżonn hu regolamenti ġodda. L-argument ikompli li jekk isir hekk ir-riċessjoni tkompli.


Dan hu argument sabiħ għax b’hekk terġa’ tintalab il-logħba ta’ Wiċċ nirbaħ jien u Irġejjen titlef int. Dan għaliex li jkun ġara hu l-ewwel daħħluna fi kriżi, wara ħallasna għaliha aħna l-konsumaturi u issa jridu jerġgħu jibqgħu għaddejjin kif kienu biex jerġgħu jagħmlu qligħ kbir.

Jekk jiġri hekk, ikun ifisser li ma tgħallimna xejn.



Nittamaw li dan il-jum ma jkunx bħall-oħrajn

Ħafna paroli sabiħ f’dan il-jum u wara ninsew kollox. Jekk verament nemmnu li rridu nħarsu d-drittijiet tal-konsumaturi nużaw dan il-jum biex dawk li b’xi mod jistgħu jinfluwenzaw id-deċiżjonijiet sew lokalment u sew fuq livell Ewropew, jadottaw dawn il-proposti tal-moviment Ewropew tal-konsumaturi biex verament niddefendu l-konsumaturi.

Published in it-Torca on 14thMarch 2010